|world issue : ◆ US / US cartoons US Designs; ◆ China / Shanghai EXPO , GuangZhou World Games , China Creativity - Beijing Olympics ; ◆ Japan / Japan Comics - comment most popular books (Chinese version)|
The best-selling academic textbook,
Contemporary Advertising (author: William F. Arens, McGraw Hill, USA)
discusses American design works' imitation, plagiarism or flattery in its ethical
issues section. Certainly this problem already existed for a number of years (European
advertisements/commercials are better and more witty than the US ads. in largest
int'l ads festivals for years )
and not just in advertisement field, not just in
non-contest design works
many awarded/winning designs are the same.
Imitation is implicit in advertisement/commercial field, imitation is the sincerest form of flatting..., but, if everyone just show homage for & follows other's excellent ideas, who is willing to be the 1st one to do the hard job ― original creativity?
|the US design||
● Ranking No.1 on
Google by keyword "comment designs in USA"
No.2 at 2022-12-8, 2021-11-4
It's easy for me to find out enough number of suspected crib-works in American advertising, graphic designs, humor, illustrations, cartoons/comics etc fields. For instance,
★ Business Week, best Advertising award ― "What shape is your business in?"(pic.9, pls. see below), this work shows lots of small fishes forming a big fish's shape ( to scare predators ). This is an advertisement being made as an ad. for the design consulting company (anderson) itself.
(1) Exact same idea already appeared in a best award(pic.10, pls. see below) in Yomiuri int'l cartoon contest held by Japanese Yomiuri newspaper, largest & most influential news in Nippon.
(2) This sort of idea already appeared in classic humorous cartoons in many places long time ago, e.g., lots of bees form an elephant in shape.
(3) This idea may imitate some animals' instinct, not human beings' creativity. According to "Totally Wild, National Geographic", small fishes (or some species) may form a "giant" to scare predators.
(4) This idea may come from an old fable too.
(5) An excellent college-level Advertising textbook written by professors in world best universities also applies this sort of idea to explain creativity ― lots of dragonflies form a fish-net in shape with the caption "the combined strengths of Fortis (a company.)".
Again and again we can see completely new, totally different, great ideas coming up from somewhere or some corners on this planet when we feel there's no room to go any further working on an old subject material, e.g., an old man in a remote island. If you are really talented person, you certainly can create a fresh idea about fishes' shape.
★ Some US excellent college-level Advertising books, like Contemporary Advertising (ch. 12, Creative Execution) by William F. Arens use an idea to teach students, a fancy woman wearing Wallis socks is extremely charming so as to make some guys in fatal status, in the same ads. campaign there're some other series-ads, one (pic.6, pls. see below) of them looks very like a very old cartoon (pic.5, pls. see below) ― just replaced an old train with a modern train, and deleted a clever idea - a bloody mark on the wall.
★ New York Ads Festival ― one among world best Ads festivals selected an old idea as winning work (pic.8 & 7, pls. see below) ― lots of "cross" instead of crossing lines on the road ( to warn drivers traffic accidents ).
★ 2 best US magazines, TIME and BusinessWeek, used similar idea ...
|| 2 Best magazines in the US use same idea (line-chart
mouth) in their cover ― see pictures on the left.
Not sure which is the most original one. In graphic design books you also can find this kind of ideas (Charts & Diagrams, 'Nigel Holmes,84).
★ Famous US editorial cartoon award, Sigma delta Chi Award, gave award to an idea similar to older one.
Living Humans as shells (cannon fodder)
original work by Rob Lawlor.
|Both cartoons use similar idea ―
left pic :Human beings as bullets for an artillery,
right pic.: human beings as bullets for a machine-gun.
Both cartoons are famous art-works.
Left one is Biro Mihaly: A haboru borzalmai ellen, Plakat Budapest, Europe, at 1912. http://www.hnm.hu/utils/Gallery.php?ItemID=213&PicNum=9
pic right won '83 Sigma delta Chi Award, also was selected as <Best Cartoons of the Year>.
★ illustration arts ― It's easy to find quite a lot of similar ideas from US best magazines, for example, merging / blending of 2 subjects (house and computer) to draw attention by violating reality were shown several times in Business Week, e.g., Acer advertisement in 1996, and some illustrations in 1998, or replacing a head with a computer-monitor, or adding a bar-code on human's face or body - repeated again and again in many media.
★ cartoon/comic arts ― It's easy to find quite a lot of similar ideas from US best newspapers, please click to see comment the US cartoons ..
left: a classic cartoon, appeared earlier. The bloody mark makes this idea much better & more witty (men made same mistake again and again) than pic. 6. and its other series ads.
right: an USA prt. ad. collected in a best ads. album,
a winning (finalist) print ad. in New York Advertising festivals, USA
Ron Chu, a best-seller cartoonist in Taiwan, has created this cartoon a lot earlier.
Best Ads Award winner, BusinessWeek, USA. (anderson's prt. ad)
best awarded work in int'l cartoon contest held by Japanese Yomiuri newspaper
★ movie arts ― An essay in the New York Times (Nov 18, 2011 ), "Film is Dead? What else is new?", mentioned that "Why aren’t there any good movies anymore?" , "movies have suffered an overall decline in quality and that the exceptions are outliers...... The past is full of glories.....", Oscar director Ang Lee also said that there're only very few excellent writers in Hollywood.
★Ending : World has been laughing China as a cheap-copy (山寨) nation, but some of their media has courage to criticize Chinese suspected art-works (pic. 11, pls. see below). From 2010 till 2012, USA has been ranked world top 2 nation in cultural soft power field by UK based Monocle, so, commenting US design arts suppose is much more difficult and challenging than commenting China's or most other nations' soft power. No matter what may happen it's right thing to encourage real things by human beings' imagination and IQ as well as by various creativity methods like visual puns, parodies, comic exaggeration, jokes, or just plain silliness, etc(ps1), and of course we should criticize evil things(ps2).
ps1: "Humor theories, mechanisms and typologies"
|Speck Speck||comic wit, resonant wit, full comedy, satire||resonant wit, full comedy||satire, full comedy|
|Goldstein and McGhee||nonsense||sexual||aggressive|
|Freud||nontendencious wit||tendencious wit||tendencious wit|
|Kelly and Soloman||pun, understatement, joke, something ludicrousness, irony||pun||satire|
|McCullough and Taylor||nonsense, pun, humor , nonsense , pun , humor||sexual, warm humor||aggressive|
|Cho||negativity, subtle, complexity, perceptual interest negativity, subtle , complexity, perceptual interest||negativity, slice-of-life, subtle, complexity, miniaturization||negativity, ludicrousness, slice-of-life, perceptual interest, miniaturization|
|Stern||verbal comedy, satiric comedy||romantic comedy||satiric comedy,physical comedy|
|Catanescu and Tom||comparison, personification ,exaggeration , pun, silliness, surprise||sarcasm|
|Toncar||pun, understatement, joke, ludicrous, irony, satire||satire|
|Buijzen and Valkenburg||slapstick, clownish, humor, surprise, misunderstanding, parody||slapstick||slapstick, satire, irony|
table above from <Humor in the Advertising Business> (2008) by Fred Beard PhD, Professor of the University of Oklahoma, USA )
ps2: In scholarly paper category, publishing first wins, however, in design field, similar ideas may be just coincidence, or by sleeping-effect, etc, but printing them to public is because those media are short of excellent editing staff, judges or just carelessness, etc.
|China's media criticized some suspected cartoon-arts : left one published in 1996, right side one in 2002.||
|left side graphic art by
artist Fukuda 福田, printed in "Graphic Imagination",
etc , right side illustration was printed in TIME, a very famous magazine USA.
|the US design||
|● This article is ranking no.1 on google.com by keyword "comment design USA" at Dec. 4, 2012. Total number of search result is 442,000,000.||
Ranking No.1 by key word
"comment graphic design by USA" on Yahoo at May 31, 2015
(The top 2 are just "Ads.", commercial advertisements)